Stamped Alternative
Outgrown Stamped Loyalty? Meet Mage.
Stamped works for getting started. But when you need full customization, deep analytics, and a platform built for loyalty - not reviews - it's time to upgrade.
7-day free trial • No credit card required • Cancel anytime
Why merchants are switching
Full customization
Deep analytics
Founder access
Shopify rating
Trusted by leading brands
Why are brands switching from Stamped?
Stamped is fine for basics. But growing brands need more than basic.
Unlimited Customization
Stamped limits you to basic colors and logos. Mage gives you complete control over widgets, panels, and dedicated loyalty landing pages.
Loyalty-First Platform
Stamped treats loyalty as an add-on to reviews. Mage is built from the ground up as a loyalty platform - it's our entire focus.
Actionable Analytics
Stamped's reporting is surface-level. Mage gives you the deep insights you need to actually optimize your program and prove ROI.
Transparent Pricing
Stamped's costs add up quickly with tiers and custom rules. Mage includes all features on every plan - no surprise bills.
Mage vs Stamped Loyalty
See what you get with a loyalty-first platform vs a reviews platform with loyalty bolted on.
| Feature | Mage |  Stamped |
|---|---|---|
| Customization & Branding | ||
Custom Loyalty Landing Pages | ||
Full Widget Customization | ||
Complete Brand Control | ||
No-Code Customization | ||
| Core Loyalty Features | ||
Points for Purchases & Actions | ||
VIP Tiers (Spend, Points, Orders) | ||
Referral Program | ||
Birthday Rewards | ||
Reward Non-Members | ||
| Analytics & Reporting | ||
Deep Program Analytics | ||
Cohort Analysis | ||
Reward Performance Tracking | ||
Customer Segment Insights | ||
| Platform & Support | ||
Loyalty-First Platform | ||
Founder-Led Support | ||
All Features on Growth ($39) | ||
Weekly Product Updates | ||
Why should you choose Mage?
The best Shopify loyalty platform for modern merchants.
Full Brand Control
Stamped gives you colors and logos. Mage gives you everything: custom widgets, panels, dedicated loyalty landing pages, and complete control over how rewards are displayed and delivered across your entire site.
Built for Loyalty, Not Reviews
Stamped's loyalty module is secondary to their review product. Mage is 100% focused on loyalty, VIP tiers, and referrals - which means deeper features and constant innovation where it matters.
Analytics That Drive Decisions
Stamped's reporting stays surface-level. Mage provides cohort analysis, reward performance tracking, and segment-level insights so you can actually optimize your program with confidence.
Founder-Led Support
With Mage, you talk directly to the founders and the team who built the product. Need help optimizing your program? Want a custom feature? We're a Slack message away.
Weekly Product Updates
We ship new features every single week. Your loyalty program improves constantly without you having to ask for it or pay extra.
Seamless Integrations
Mage integrates deeply with Klaviyo, JudgeMe, Gorgias, and your entire tech stack. No walled gardens, no disconnected experiences.
Reasons to choose Mage
Stamped Alternative: Why loyalty-first brands are upgrading to Mage.
Stop Outgrowing Your Loyalty Platform
Stamped Loyalty works fine when you're just getting started. But as your brand grows, you'll quickly hit the walls: rigid templates, basic analytics, and features that don't go deep enough. Why set yourself up for a migration later when you can start with the right foundation now? Mage is built to grow with you from day one.
Your Brand Deserves More Than Basic Customization
Stamped lets you change colors and add a logo. That's about it. The widget, referral interface, and VIP pages all follow the same rigid structure. With Mage, every touchpoint is fully customizable - from dedicated loyalty landing pages to how rewards are displayed, to how messages are delivered. Your loyalty program should feel like a natural extension of your brand, not a generic add-on.
Loyalty Should Be the Focus, Not an Afterthought
Stamped built their platform around reviews, then added loyalty as a secondary feature. That means loyalty always plays second fiddle. Mage is built from the ground up as a loyalty-first platform. Our entire engineering team, product roadmap, and feature development is focused on making your loyalty program the best it can be.
Analytics You Can Actually Act On
Stamped's reporting shows you surface-level metrics. But can you run cohort analyses? Isolate reward performance? Measure long-term impact across customer segments? With Mage, you get the deep analytics you need to make data-informed decisions about your program - not just vanity metrics.
A loyalty platform, not an afterthought
Unlike Stamped's bolt-on loyalty module, Mage is built from the ground up for loyalty: points, VIP tiers, referrals, and seamless integrations.
Loyalty Points
Reward customers for purchases, social shares, birthdays, and more.
Explore Points
VIP Tiers
Create exclusive tiers based on spend, points, or order count.
Explore VIP Tiers
Referral Program
Turn loyal customers into brand ambassadors with referral rewards.
Explore Referrals
Integrations
Connect with Klaviyo, JudgeMe, Gorgias, and your favorite Shopify apps.
View Integrations
See Your Loyalty Program in Action
Customers earn points, unlock VIP tiers, and redeem rewards — all while you watch engagement grow.
Simple Setup, Powerful Results
Create earning rules and rewards in minutes. Full control over your loyalty experience.
2,550 points until Platinum
Available Rewards
Real-Time Engagement
Watch as customers earn points, redeem rewards, and climb VIP tiers.
Sarah M.
Made a purchase
+150 pts
James K.
Redeemed $10 off
-500 pts
Emily R.
Reached Gold Tier
★ VIP
Michael C.
Referred a friend
+200 pts
Lisa T.
Birthday bonus
+100 pts
David W.
Free shipping reward
-300 pts
Anna P.
Instagram follow
+25 pts
Chris L.
Reached Platinum
★ VIP
Sarah M.
Made a purchase
+150 pts
James K.
Redeemed $10 off
-500 pts
Emily R.
Reached Gold Tier
★ VIP
Michael C.
Referred a friend
+200 pts
Lisa T.
Birthday bonus
+100 pts
David W.
Free shipping reward
-300 pts
Anna P.
Instagram follow
+25 pts
Chris L.
Reached Platinum
★ VIP
Premium features from just $39/month
Unlike Stamped's tiered pricing that adds up quickly, Mage Growth includes everything. Transparent pricing, no hidden fees.
Startup
For growing brands with more needs
Get started with:
- 500 monthly orders included
- Shopify POS integration
- VIP Tiers based on spend, points or orders
- Access to all earning rules
- Access to all rewards
- Email Customization
- Analytics
- Integrations
Growth
For established brands scaling up
Everything in Startup, plus:
- Lower cost usage-based pricing
- Access to all earning rules
- Access to all rewards
- Loyalty Points Expiry
- Dedicated Loyalty and Referrals page
- Access to all integrations
- Embedded account page widget
- Priority Live Chat Support
Enterprise
For high-volume stores with custom needs
Everything in Growth, plus:
- Our best usage-based pricing rate
- Checkout loyalty features
- Full Migration Support
- Dedicated account manager
- Priority support
- Advanced reporting and analytics
- Custom onboarding
- Custom integrations
Frequently Asked Questions
Everything you need to know about switching from Stamped to Mage.
How is Mage different from Stamped Loyalty?
The biggest difference is focus. Stamped built their platform around reviews and added loyalty as a secondary feature. Mage is built from the ground up as a loyalty-first platform. That means deeper customization, better analytics, and features specifically designed for loyalty programs.
Can I customize my loyalty program more with Mage?
Absolutely. With Stamped, you're limited to colors and logos. Mage gives you complete control: custom loyalty landing pages, fully customizable widgets and panels, and flexibility in how rewards are displayed and delivered across your site.
Is the analytics really that much better?
Yes. Stamped offers surface-level reporting. Mage provides cohort analyses, reward performance tracking, and segment-level insights. You can actually measure long-term impact and make data-informed decisions about your program.
How does pricing compare?
Stamped's pricing adds up quickly when you add tiers, actions, and custom rules. Mage includes all features on every plan with transparent pricing - no surprise add-on fees.
Can you migrate my data from Stamped?
Yes. We'll import your customer points, VIP tier statuses, and program settings. Our team handles the technical work - most migrations complete within 24-48 hours with zero downtime.
What if I'm also using Stamped for reviews?
No problem. Many brands use Mage for loyalty alongside other review platforms like JudgeMe. Mage integrates seamlessly with your existing tech stack - you don't have to bundle everything together.
Try Mage for free for your Shopify store
Instantly get access to a fully fledged loyalty program
Points program
Reward your customers for purchases, birthdays, social follows & more.
Ways to reward
Reward customers with many different types of rewards.
VIP Tiers
Reward your most loyal customers with exclusive benefits.
Ready to increase customer lifetime value?
Join 100+ Shopify stores using Mage to turn one-time buyers into loyal repeat customers.
"Great app! User friendly and straightforward. The customer service team has been great and so helpful with some minor tweaks I wanted to make and customize."