BON vs Stamped: 2026 Comparison

Every ecommerce brand faces the same puzzle: choose a loyalty app, or go all-in with a bundle that handles reviews too. The decision feels weighty. You're not just picking software—you're choosing how customers will interact with your brand for the next 18 months.

Except here's what most merchants get wrong. They assume loyalty and review platforms are interchangeable commodities. They're not. The difference between BON Loyalty and Stamped.io isn't minor. It's architectural.

BON Loyalty is laser-focused. It does loyalty exceptionally well—points, tiers, referrals—and it does it affordably. Stamped.io is the Swiss Army knife. One platform handles reviews, loyalty, and user-generated content as an integrated ecosystem. They're solving different problems for different businesses.

This comparison cuts through the noise. We'll show you exactly where each platform excels, where each stumbles, and which one actually makes sense for your store in 2026.

What is BON Loyalty?

BON Loyalty is a Shopify native loyalty and rewards app built for merchants who want sophisticated retention tools without enterprise pricing. It's the choice for brands that prioritize loyalty mechanics—and only loyalty mechanics.

The platform handles everything you'd expect: points systems, VIP tiers, referral programs, and dynamic engagement tools like order boosters and limited-time point offers. The interface is straightforward. The setup is fast. And the pricing doesn't require a finance committee approval.

Working with BON Loyalty customers, I've noticed they tend to be merchants who already have review solutions in place (Judge.me, Loox, or similar). They're not looking for a bundled catch-all. They're looking for pure loyalty execution.

BON Loyalty Pros

Simple 'set and forget' logic for lean teams. Configuration is intuitive enough that a single person—with minimal technical knowledge—can manage the entire program. Rules don't require custom code.

Seamless integration with Shopify POS. This matters more than most realize. Omnichannel brands need in-store and online loyalty to sync perfectly. BON handles this without friction.

Transparent pricing for growing stores. Entry starts free. Scaling is predictable. You know exactly what you're paying and what you're getting at each tier.

Comprehensive Loyalty Features. Points-based systems, VIP tiers, and advanced referral programs with anti-cheat features. Includes order boosters and limited-time point offers for dynamic engagement.

Customization and Branding. Highly customizable loyalty pages and robust branding options seamlessly integrate with your store's aesthetic.

Analytics for Program Performance. A dedicated section to monitor and analyze loyalty program effectiveness.

Extensive Multilingual Support. Supports over 250 languages, crucial for international merchants.

Advanced Technical Support. B2B tiers and Hydrogen/Headless support for complex setups.

Positive User Ratings. Maintains a 4.8 out of 5 rating on G2 with strong customer satisfaction.

Free Entry-Level Pricing. Get started without financial commitment.

BON Loyalty Cons

Lacks integrated review management features. If you need review collection, moderation, and display on one platform, you'll need a separate tool.

Interface feels basic compared to modern specialists. It prioritizes functionality over visual polish. Some teams find the dashboard dated relative to newer competitors.

No dedicated SEO reviews page. Unlike platforms designed specifically for reviews, BON doesn't create optimized review landing pages for search visibility.

Primary focus on loyalty. Core strength centers on loyalty and rewards, potentially offering less depth in advanced review functionalities compared to what a customer loyalty program entails that include reviews as core features.

What is Stamped.io?

Stamped.io operates from a different philosophy. It's an all-in-one platform bundling customer reviews, loyalty programs, and user-generated content (UGC) into one ecosystem. Think of it as an integrated solution designed for brands that want social proof, retention, and community engagement on a single dashboard.

The platform is positioned as premium—higher price point, broader feature set, deeper analytics. It's built for brands that view reviews, loyalty, and UGC not as separate functions but as interconnected drivers of trust and repeat purchase behavior.

I've worked with Stamped.io users who are typically scaling DTC brands or established ecommerce players. They've moved past the "pick one tool" stage. They want orchestration.

Stamped.io Pros

Affordable bundle for reviews and rewards. Single platform handles what typically requires two or three separate tools, potentially reducing overall software spend.

Official Google and TikTok Shopping partner. Direct integrations with major platforms mean your reviews and content syndicate automatically to where customers actually shop.

AI sentiment analysis for customer insights. Automatically analyzes review language to surface themes, pain points, and opportunities. Saves hours of manual analysis.

All-in-One Comprehensive Platform. Combines customer reviews, loyalty programs, and UGC features as a unified solution.

Robust Review Features. Extensive review collection (automated requests, in-email forms, photo/video reviews), versatile display (widgets, Google Seller Ratings), and broad distribution (Google, social media).

Advanced Loyalty Programs. Sophisticated points and rewards systems, VIP programs, and referral programs.

Holistic and Granular Analytics. Complete view of loyalty program impact with granular insights into VIP tiers, point redemptions, purchase frequency, cohort behaviors, and loyalty-attributed revenue. This is where Stamped.io pulls ahead. The analytics tell a story traditional apps miss.

Proven Customer Impact. New York & Company achieved a "97% Repeat Purchase Rate with VIP Customers." GURU Beverage boosted review engagement to a "53% Open Rate." These aren't hypothetical benefits—they're documented results.

Positive User Ratings. Maintains 4.7 out of 5 on G2.

Large Shopify App Store Presence. 3,702 reviews indicate a substantial user base and proven reliability.

Free Entry-Level Pricing. Accessible starting point.

Stamped.io Cons

Buggy platform reported by some users. Performance issues and occasional glitches reported in user reviews, particularly during high-traffic periods.

Advanced analytics restricted to high-tier plans. The intelligence that makes Stamped.io compelling—loyalty-attributed revenue tracking, cohort analysis—lives behind premium pricing.

Higher pricing tiers. Positioned as premium, prices escalate quickly. Full functionality requires significant investment.

Key Features Tied to Higher Tiers. Video reviews, Google Seller Ratings, and advanced loyalty bundles reserved for higher plans.

BON vs Stamped: Side-by-Side Comparison

Pricing & Value Proposition

BON Loyalty: Free plan available. Paid tiers scale from approximately $49/month to $349/month. The value is in transparency—you know what you're paying and what you get at each level. This appeals to budget-conscious merchants scaling from small to mid-size operations.

Stamped.io: Starts free but paid plans begin around $23/month. The catch? Advanced features—the stuff that justifies the investment—live in higher tiers ($99+/month). For a full loyalty and review bundle with analytics, expect $200+/month. The paradox: entry price looks lower, total cost of ownership is higher.

The Real Difference: BON favors simplicity at scale. Stamped.io front-loads capability but back-loads pricing. Choose BON if budget predictability matters. Choose Stamped if you need features now and can justify the investment.

Core Functionality: Loyalty & Rewards Programs

Both platforms handle points, tiers, and referrals competently. The nuance lies in sophistication.

BON Loyalty excels at straightforward mechanics. Points per dollar spent. Tier thresholds. Referral bonuses. The "set and forget" nature appeals to lean teams. You configure it once, monitor it monthly.

Stamped.io layers sophistication onto loyalty. Behavioral triggers. Cohort-based rewards. Loyalty-attributed revenue tracking shows not just if your program grows, but exactly which customers it moves and by how much. For data-driven brands, this is the difference between guessing and knowing.

Both support strategies for creating compelling VIP tiers, but Stamped's analytics reveal which tier structures actually drive incremental revenue.

Core Functionality: Customer Reviews & UGC

This is where divergence sharpens.

BON Loyalty treats reviews as secondary. You can collect them. You can display basic widgets. But the depth isn't there. No photo/video reviews out-of-the-box. No Google Seller Ratings integration. No syndication to TikTok Shop.

Stamped.io was built for this. Automated review requests. In-email collection. Native photo and video support. Google Seller Ratings integration. Direct TikTok and Google Shopping syndication. It's built to leverage leveraging user-generated content (UGC) effectively as a retention and acquisition engine, not an afterthought.

If reviews matter to your strategy—and for most brands, they should—Stamped.io is the obvious choice.

Ease of Use & Setup

BON Loyalty is genuinely easy. Dashboard is clean. Workflows are linear. A non-technical founder can have it live in two hours.

Stamped.io is more complex. More features mean more configuration options. Setup takes longer. But once configured, workflows are powerful.

Winner depends on your tolerance for configuration. Quick start? BON. Long-term sophistication? Stamped.

Customer Support

Both platforms offer responsive support. BON users report quick email and chat responses. Stamped has a strong knowledge base and dedicated account support at higher tiers. Neither is a weakness.

Integrations

BON Loyalty integrates deeply with Shopify POS and works with email platforms like Klaviyo and Omnisend. It handles the Shopify ecosystem well.

Stamped.io has broader reach: seamless integrations with essential tools like Klaviyo, Google Shopping, TikTok Shop, and extensive email provider support. The integration breadth is notable—especially the direct partnership channels with Google and TikTok.

Analytics & Reporting

Here's where Stamped.io separates decisively.

BON gives you program metrics: enrollments, points issued, redemptions. Functional analytics.

Stamped provides key loyalty analytics to track for revenue growth—including loyalty-attributed revenue, customer cohort behavior, VIP tier performance, and review impact on conversion. This is business intelligence, not activity reporting.

Customization & Branding

Both allow branded loyalty pages and customizable widgets. BON's customization is more straightforward. Stamped offers deeper control over review widget styling and email templates.

Target Audience & Best For

BON Loyalty: Small-to-mid-size Shopify stores with established review solutions. Merchants who value speed, simplicity, and predictable costs. International brands (multilingual support is exceptional). Brands with omnichannel operations (POS integration is seamless).

Stamped.io: Growing DTC brands that view reviews and loyalty as interconnected. Brands selling on multiple channels (Google, TikTok, Amazon). Merchants who need analytics to prove program ROI. Brands with budget allocated for sophistication.

Why Choose BON Loyalty?

Select BON if you need loyalty execution without complexity. You have reviews handled elsewhere. Your team is small. Your budget is tight. You want setup in hours, not days. You operate internationally and need multilingual support.

BON is what it claims: a focused, affordable, reliable loyalty platform. It doesn't try to be everything. For most small merchants, that honesty is exactly what you need.

Why Choose Stamped.io?

Select Stamped if you're scaling. You need reviews and loyalty integrated. You sell on multiple platforms (Google Shopping, TikTok). You want analytics that prove impact. You have the budget for premium tools that actually justify their cost through intelligence and automation.

Stamped makes sense when retention strategy is sophisticated enough to warrant sophisticated tools.

Conclusion: Making Your Decision in 2026

The choice between BON and Stamped is really a choice between philosophies.

BON says: "We do loyalty. We do it well. We do it affordably. Use another tool for reviews."

Stamped says: "Reviews, loyalty, and UGC are one system. Pay for integration and intelligence."

Neither is universally correct. Both have documented success. Both have happy users.

The real question for your business: Is your review strategy mature enough to deserve premium tools? Can you justify $200+/month for integrated analytics and automation? Or does $49-99/month for pure loyalty execution better serve your current stage?

Consider your growth trajectory next. Where are you headed in 18 months? If towards omnichannel and multiple sales platforms, Stamped's syndication partnerships become valuable. If towards operational efficiency at your current scale, BON's simplicity pays dividends.

There's also no rule against starting with BON, proving loyalty ROI, then migrating to Stamped as you scale. Many successful brands follow exactly this path.

Build your building a comprehensive customer retention strategy with whatever tools let you execute consistently. Then measure. Adjust. Migrate if the data demands it.

The platform that makes sense is the one you'll actually maintain and optimize. For most merchants in 2026, that's either BON's focused efficiency or Stamped's integrated intelligence. Both are solid. Pick the one that matches your team's bandwidth and ambitions.

Frequently Asked Questions

Can I migrate my existing loyalty data from one platform to another?

Both BON and Stamped support data export. Migration is possible but requires manual configuration on the new platform. Customer point balances and tier history typically transfer. Email your support team for specific migration steps before committing.

Which app offers better support for photo and video reviews?

Stamped.io has native photo and video review capabilities with built-in collection and display. BON requires third-party review apps (like Loox or Judge.me) for photo/video functionality.

Do both platforms work with Shopify POS?

BON Loyalty integrates seamlessly with Shopify POS for omnichannel loyalty. Stamped.io supports POS but the integration is less seamless than BON's native setup.

What's the realistic monthly cost for a growing store using both platforms fully?

BON Loyalty typically runs $49-149/month for growing stores. Stamped.io with full features (reviews, loyalty, advanced analytics) ranges $99-249/month. Budget accordingly—both are management costs, not one-time purchases.

TLDR

BON Loyalty is the focused, affordable choice for merchants who want pure loyalty execution and handle reviews separately. Stamped.io is the premium, integrated platform for brands that view reviews, loyalty, and UGC as one interconnected system. BON wins on simplicity and cost. Stamped wins on analytics and feature depth. Choose based on your current complexity, budget, and growth trajectory.