Alternatives

The modern alternative to legacy loyalty

Ambitious Shopify brands switch to Mage for modern Customer Accounts, a no-code editor, and every feature included on every plan. See how Mage compares to your current app.

Side by side

Compare Mage to your current loyalty app

Yotpo logo
Save 20–50% on your billAlternative to Yotpo
LoyaltyLion logo
~30% cheaper, modern stackAlternative to LoyaltyLion
Rivo logo
~30% cheaper, no-code + devAlternative to Rivo
Smile.io logo
Outgrow basic loyaltyAlternative to Smile.io
Stamped logo
Modern Shopify-native stackAlternative to Stamped
Growave logo
Unified Customer AccountAlternative to Growave
Joy Loyalty logo
Outgrow starter rewardsAlternative to Joy Loyalty
BON Loyalty logo
From $49, scales with youAlternative to BON Loyalty
Appstle Loyalty logo
Built loyalty-firstAlternative to Appstle Loyalty
Swym Wishlist logo
Wishlist + loyalty bundledAlternative to Swym Wishlist
Swish (Wishlist King) logo
Flat $49 — any Shopify planAlternative to Swish (Wishlist King)

Shopify Loyalty App FAQ

Focus on three things: feature access, integration depth, and support quality. The best loyalty app for Shopify gives you points, VIP tiers, referrals, and analytics without feature-gating behind expensive plans. Deep integrations with Klaviyo, checkout extensibility, and review apps matter more than a long feature list. And when something breaks, you want real support, not a chatbot.

Mage handles full data migration for you. Points balances, VIP tier status, and referral history all transfer over. The process typically takes under 48 hours with zero downtime for your customers. Your existing members keep their earned rewards, and the transition is seamless from their perspective.

Three things stand out. First, every feature is included on every plan with no gating points behind one tier and VIP behind another. Second, Mage is built exclusively for Shopify, which means native checkout integration, Shopify Flow actions, and POS support that actually works. Third, you get direct founder-led support instead of ticket queues.

Yes. Mage imports your existing points balances, tier placements, and referral data from any major loyalty provider. Customers won't notice the switch as their balances stay intact and rewards continue uninterrupted. We coordinate the cutover to make sure nothing falls through the cracks.

Mage consistently ranks among the top-rated Shopify loyalty apps for brands that want enterprise-grade features without enterprise pricing. All features included, no annual contracts, usage-based pricing that scales with you. For growing Shopify brands that have outgrown basic loyalty tools, Mage is purpose-built to be the upgrade.

Most loyalty apps gate their best features (VIP tiers, advanced analytics, custom branding) behind premium plans that can run $200-$500/month. Mage includes everything on every plan with transparent, usage-based pricing. You pay for what you use, not what you might need someday. No annual contracts, no surprise invoices.

Comparisons help, but they often miss what matters most: how the app actually performs in your store. We publish transparent feature-by-feature comparisons against every major competitor so you can see exactly where Mage differs. The fastest way to decide is to install the free plan and test it with your own products and customers.

Active campaigns and promotions transfer cleanly. Mage's migration process preserves in-progress point multipliers, active referral links, and pending rewards. We work with you to time the switch so no customer is left mid-transaction. Most brands complete the move between campaigns for the smoothest experience.