
A tiered loyalty program gives customers better benefits as they reach defined levels, usually through spend, points or orders. The way you set up those levels decides who feels rewarded, how often customers come back and how much the program costs you. I've worked with hundreds of Shopify merchants on their loyalty programs over the past three years, and for this guide we compared how 34 real programs, from Sephora to Dr. Squatch, set up their tiers.
This guide is written by Kris, co-founder of Mage. Mage is a loyalty and customer accounts platform for Shopify, and we sell VIP tiers, so I say where they are a poor fit.
The short version
- Most programs keep it simple: 31 of the 34 use three or four tiers, and I recommend two to four.
- Qualify customers on spend, measured over a rolling 12 months or over a calendar year with a year of protection.
- Set the first paid tier just above your average order value, so a normal first order leaves the customer a little short.
- Skip tiers if your customers buy rarely or unpredictably, or if your prices range from a few dollars to thousands.
“I looked into so many different integrations for loyalty and referrals for our Shopify Store, but no one impressed me more than Mage on human connection, customer service, and value.”


Read the Reelie case study →
How we researched this guide
The program data comes from our own brand breakdowns, each linked below. For each one we read the brand's program pages and terms in October 2026 and recorded the tiers, thresholds, status rules and perks, so every breakdown states the date it was checked. Programs change, so check a brand's current page before copying anything. The recommendations come from my own experience working with merchants.
What is a tiered loyalty program?
A tiered loyalty program assigns customers to levels after they reach a qualification threshold. A simple version uses a base tier at sign-up, a second tier after a spend target, and a third for the most valuable customers. Each tier needs a status signal and a practical reason to care, such as a higher earn rate, early access, free shipping or a larger birthday reward.
Points programs focus on a balance: customers earn points, then redeem them. Tiers add a longer-term goal. Instead of asking only "what can I redeem today?", customers can see what another purchase unlocks.
How 34 real programs set up their tiers
Here is the pattern across all 34, taken from our breakdowns as checked in October 2026.
| Question | What we found |
|---|---|
| Number of tiers | 3 tiers in 20 programs, 4 in 11, 2 in 2 (H&M, ThirdLove), 6 in 1 (Represent). 31 of 34 use three or four |
| What qualifies a customer | Spend in 18, points in 15, order count in 1 (Lola Blankets). Several points programs earn 1 point per $1, so they work like spend |
| How long status is measured | A fixed calendar or program year in 15, an individual 12-month clock in 12, lifetime in 2, not clearly stated in 5 |
| Carry-through | 14 let a tier last for the rest of the year you qualify in, plus the whole of the next year |
| Earn rate by tier | Rises with tier in 13, the same at every tier in 16, other or not published in 5 |
The 34 programs
| Brand | Tiers | Qualifies on | How long status lasts | Earn rate by tier |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Sephora | 3 | Spend: $350, $1,000 | Calendar year, plus the next | Same (1 per $1) |
| Ulta Beauty | 3 | Spend: $500, $1,200 | Calendar year, plus the next | Rises (1, 1.25, 1.5) |
| Lancôme | 4 | Points: 2,000, 6,500, 20,000 | Enrollment to the end of the following calendar year | Same (10 per $1) |
| M·A·C | 3 | Spend: $150, $500 | Calendar year, plus the next | Same |
| Charlotte Tilbury | 3 | Spend: $150, $400 | 365 days from reaching the level | Same (1 per $1) |
| Kylie Cosmetics | 4 | Spend: $100, $250, $500 | Rolling 12 months | Rises (1, 1, 1.25, 1.5) |
| e.l.f. Beauty | 3 | Points: 1,000, 2,000 | Calendar year, plus the next | Same (10 per $1) |
| Starface | 3 | Spend: $100, $200 | Not stated | Rises (1, 1.25, 1.5) |
| OSEA | 4 | Spend: $200, $400, plus a subscriber lane | 12 months from reaching the tier | Rises (1, 2, 3) |
| Club OUAI | 3 | Spend: $150, $250 | 12-month period | Rises (1, 1.5, 2) |
| Nordstrom | 4 | Net spend: $500, $5,000, $15,000 (top tier is card-only) | Calendar year | Set by the card |
| adidas | 4 | Points: 1,000, 3,000, 9,000 | Points last 365 days | Same (10 per $1) |
| Foot Locker | 3 | Spend: $250, $500 | Program year, plus the next | Same (100 per $1) |
| lululemon | 3 | Spend: $500, $1,000 | Calendar year, plus the next | No points |
| ALO Yoga | 3 | Points at 1 per $1: 300, 1,000 | 12 months | Same (1 per $1) |
| HUGO BOSS | 4 | Points at 1 per $1: 751, 2,501, 7,500 | Calendar year sets the next year | Same (1 per $1) |
| H&M | 2 | Points: 500 for the top tier | Membership year | Same (1 per $1) |
| Kith | 3 | Lifetime points: 2,000, 10,000 | Lifetime | Not by tier |
| Represent | 6 | Lifetime points: 250, 500, 1,000, 5,000, 10,000 | Lifetime, no demotion | Not published |
| Pandora | 3 | Top tier at $400 in 12 months | Rolling 12 months | Same |
| Starbucks | 3 | Stars: 500, 2,500 | Rolling 12 months | Rises (1, 1.2, 1.7) |
| Chick-fil-A | 4 | Points: 1,000, 4,000, 10,000 | Calendar year, plus the next | Rises (10, 11, 12, 13 per $1) |
| GHOST | 4 | Status points: 5,000, 12,500, 25,000 | Calendar year, plus the next | Not published |
| Our Place | 4 | Spend: $200, $400, $600 | Rolling 12 months | Same (1 per $1) |
| Lola Blankets | 3 | Orders: 3 to 5, 6 or more | Calendar year, plus the next | Rises (1, 1.5, 2) |
| Princess Polly | 4 | Points: 300, 700, 2,500 | 12 months from reaching the tier | Same (1 per $1) |
| Dr. Squatch | 3 | Spend: $20, $75, $150 (the entry tier needs $20) | Rolling year | Rises (1, 1, 2) |
| Moroccanoil | 3 | Points: 150, 400 | Not published | Same |
| Naturium | 3 | Spend: $300, $500 a year | Calendar year | Same (1 per $1) |
| INKEY List | 3 | Spend: $70, $170 | Last 365 days | Same (5 per $1) |
| Oh Polly | 4 | Points: 2,000, 5,000, 10,000 | 12 months from entering a tier | Same (5 per $1) |
| ThirdLove | 2 | Spend: $250 a year | Calendar year, plus the next | Rises (1, 2) |
| PetSmart | 3 | Spend: $500, $1,000 a year | Calendar year, plus the next | Rises (10, 12, 14 per $1) |
| Death Wish Coffee | 3 | Points held: 601, 1,001 | Points last a year | Rises (1, 3, 5) |
Read the full breakdown for each brand: Sephora, Ulta Beauty, Lancôme, M·A·C, Charlotte Tilbury, Kylie Cosmetics, e.l.f. Beauty, Starface, OSEA, Club OUAI, Nordstrom, adidas, Foot Locker, lululemon, ALO Yoga, HUGO BOSS, H&M, Kith, Represent, Pandora, Starbucks, Chick-fil-A, GHOST, Our Place, Lola Blankets, Princess Polly, Dr. Squatch, Moroccanoil, Naturium, INKEY List, Oh Polly, ThirdLove, PetSmart, Death Wish Coffee.
Thresholds are the ones each brand publishes for tiers above the entry level, and "plus the next" means a tier lasts for the rest of the year it is earned in and the whole of the following year.
What qualifies a customer
Spend is the most common basis, and several of the points programs are spend in disguise: ALO Yoga and HUGO BOSS award 1 point per $1, so their thresholds are dollar amounts. Order count is rare. Lola Blankets is the only program in the set that counts orders, which means a customer who prefers one large purchase is not penalized. I think spend is the right measure for almost every store, and I explain why below.
How long status lasts
Just under half use a fixed calendar or program year, and about a third give each customer an individual 12-month clock. Only Kith and Represent use lifetime status, and Represent goes further: members never drop back down. The common compromise is carry-through. In 14 programs, including Sephora, Ulta, M·A·C and lululemon, a customer who reaches a tier keeps it for the rest of that year and the whole of the next, so a late-year upgrade is not wiped out by a January reset.
What happens when a customer falls short
Most programs say that a customer who misses the threshold moves to the tier their activity supports. Some say nothing: Ulta, Starface, Club OUAI, Foot Locker, ALO Yoga and Kith publish no shortfall rule. A returned order can also lower a tier: HUGO BOSS, ThirdLove and Pandora all say so. Only ThirdLove mentions a grace period, a 30 day grace period, and its terms do not explain what it covers. A grace period, a short window after a customer misses a threshold in which they keep the tier or can still requalify, is our suggestion for a soft landing, not something most brands publish.
Do higher tiers earn faster?
Often not. The earn rate rises with tier in 13 of the 34 (Ulta, Kylie Cosmetics, Starbucks, Death Wish Coffee and ThirdLove among them) and stays the same in 16. Sephora's status does not change the earn rate; it opens rewards that lower tiers cannot redeem. Our Place says its tiers add access, not a better rate, and Naturium's tiers add access such as flash sales, not a higher earn rate. Where the rate does rise, the steps can be large: Death Wish Coffee goes from 1 to 3 to 5 points per $1, and ThirdLove doubles from 1 to 2 at Platinum.
What top tiers give
Top tiers spend their budget in three ways. Shipping is one: Kylie Cosmetics lowers its free-shipping minimum from $40 to $30 to none as members move up, and ThirdLove gives Gold free shipping from $75 and Platinum free shipping on every order. Access is another: ALO Yoga adds invite-only experiences at its top tier, Oh Polly adds events and giveaways at Gold and Platinum, and Death Wish Coffee gives its top rank early access to sales. Services are the third: Charlotte Tilbury's levels spend on service, including a personal Pro Makeup Artist, and ThirdLove's Platinum members get a VIP stylist and a free pair of underwear each quarter. Birthday rewards often step up too, such as Oh Polly's 10 to 25% discount and ThirdLove's $15 and $20 gifts. For how to choose and run these perks for your best customers, see our guide to the VIP loyalty program.
Unusual designs worth knowing about
- Represent's tiers are permanent: members never drop back down, and the tier sets a lasting discount.
- Lola Blankets counts orders, not dollars, so the first tiers are reached by repeat purchase.
- Pandora treats the first purchase as a gate: members on the entry tier cannot spend points until they reach Silver.
- Chick-fil-A runs two clocks: points never expire, but status resets every 1 January.
- GHOST keeps a separate points balance for status, so redeeming rewards never pushes a member down a tier.
- Kith, HUGO BOSS and Princess Polly use points only to set status: members cannot spend them.
What I recommend
These recommendations come from my experience with hundreds of merchants, set against what the 34 programs do.
Qualify on spend
My rule is to make tiers depend on how much a customer spends. What a store cares about is how much a customer spends, not how many points or orders they have, and spend is also simple for customers to understand. Points suit a few special cases, such as challenges or meet-ups where members use points in a particular way, and order count suits a few merchant edge cases or works in combination with spend or points. Across the 34 programs, 18 qualify on spend and 15 on points, so the market is more mixed than my advice, but many of the points programs behave like spend anyway.
Use two to four tiers
Two to four tiers is the range I recommend: a base tier plus one to three levels above it. Of the 34 programs, 33 sit in that range and 31 use three or four. More tiers create more admin work and more confusion, and each extra level needs its own reason to exist. Mage supports up to 10 tiers, but I do not recommend using that many. Our guide to how many VIP tiers a program should have goes into the reasoning, and designing VIP tiers covers the benefits.
Use a rolling 12 months, or a calendar year with protection
I prefer a rolling 12-month window, because customers have to keep spending to keep their tier. A calendar year is also common, but without protection it has a flaw: a customer can reach a high tier in December and lose it a few days later, when the new year resets progress. Turning on one year of protection fixes that. In Mage this is the Protect tier status option: a customer who earns a tier keeps it through the end of the following calendar year, and once protection ends they land on whichever tier their activity now supports. I see that as a fair system. Rolling and calendar windows both need clear communication, because customers have to understand when their status ends.
Set the first paid tier just above average order value
If your data is thin, anchor thresholds to average order value. Tier 1 is the sign-up. Tier 2 sits just above AOV, so a normal first order leaves the customer a little short: either the basket grows as they try to reach it, or you have a genuine reason to remarket. Tier 3 sits at roughly twice AOV, and higher tiers step up from there. By tier 2 or 3 the cost of acquiring the customer is long covered, which is what lets the rewards scale. I explain the reasoning in the video below, and the tier thresholds chapter of the customer journey masterclass covers it in more detail.
For comparison, in dollars the first step above the entry tier runs from $20 (Dr. Squatch) to $751 (HUGO BOSS) across the programs that publish it, and most sit between $100 and $500. These figures are indicative: where a program uses points, we converted at its published rate.
Reward tiers with things customers want
The perks I see working are higher store credit cashback (for example 5% rising to 10%), automatic free shipping, early access to sales and exclusive events. Among the 34 programs the mix is similar: shipping steps, access and events, and services, with the earn rate rising in 13 of them. Whatever you choose, the benefit needs to be worth the effort of reaching the tier. Do not copy another store's thresholds: their order value, returns, margin and buying cycle are not yours.
When tiers are the wrong tool
Tiers do not suit every brand, and the decision is situational. I would hold back on a VIP tier program when:
- The brand does not want any customer to feel excluded. Tiers work by giving some customers more than others. If your brand is built on everyone being treated the same, a status ladder works against that.
- Purchase frequency is unpredictable. A threshold measured over a window only motivates when customers buy in a rhythm they can plan around. If orders arrive at random, progress is hard to show and harder to chase.
- Prices range very widely. A store selling items at $1 to $10 alongside items at $1,000 or more has a spend problem: one large order can send a customer to the top tier, while a customer who buys small items every month never gets near it.
- Customers buy about once a year, or less. This covers very high-end jewelry. A 12-month window is crossed by a single order or never, so the progress bar has nothing to show between purchases and the next tier gives no reason to come back sooner.
- The product line is very small. With little new to buy, a higher tier has little to unlock.
These explanations are my reasoning, not a measurement. In these cases a flat reward often works better: a store credit rate that is the same for everyone, a wishlist, and personal recognition. MiaDonna, a fine jewelry brand, is an example. Its published case study describes a flat store credit reward of $1 back for every $20 spent, with a wishlist and account upsells, and does not mention tiers. Our guide to a jewelry loyalty program covers that approach.
Does tier status change customer behavior?
The evidence is mostly correlational. Higher-tier customers spend more, but they may already have been more loyal, so a comparison of members and non-members does not prove tiers caused the extra purchases. A 2017 NIQ article reported that Platinum and Gold members, 16% of loyalty program shoppers, accounted for over 51% of loyalty program revenue. It does not say which retailer or how many shoppers, and it advises caution because tiers are retailer-specific, so treat it as an illustration of how concentrated spending is, not a target for a Shopify store.
The test that matters is incrementality: whether customers buy sooner, more often or more because of the tier, compared with a similar group without it. A holdout group is the cleanest way to find out. Our DTC marketing guide has a worked break-even example, and the loyalty program metrics that matter are the numbers to track by tier.
How tiered loyalty works on Shopify
Shopify holds the customer and order data that makes tiering possible. Shopify customer segments are dynamic, rule-based lists that add or remove customers as they meet criteria. A loyalty app manages the progression rules, benefits, rewards and the customer-facing status layer.
Mage supports spend, points or order-based tier entry, with lifetime, calendar-year and rolling-year qualification windows. A customer's rolling year starts when they first enter the VIP program. Calendar-year and rolling-year programs have two optional protections, both off by default: never downgrading the highest tier, and Protect tier status, which keeps a tier through the end of the following calendar year. Progress updates when an order is paid, and Mage applies Shopify tags in the format "Mage VIP Tier: [Tier Name]". Refunds reduce spend-based tier totals. Customers see progress through the loyalty page and Mage Accounts, and rewards apply at checkout with no code to copy. A Shopify VIP tiers setup can show benefits as a comparison table or cards.
| Decision | Options | What to check |
|---|---|---|
| What qualifies a customer | Spend, points, orders | Spend is my default |
| Thresholds | Base tier plus one to three levels | AOV, order frequency, margin |
| Status window | Lifetime, calendar year, rolling year | How often customers buy |
| Protection | None, protect tier status, never downgrade the top tier | Whether year-end resets would surprise customers |
| Benefits | Cashback, shipping, early access, events, rewards | Cost of each perk and whether customers notice it |
Examples from Mage customers
These are Mage customers' own published results. Case-study figures compare members with non-members or are self-reported, so they show how the programs are built, not that tiers caused the numbers.
West Coast Goalkeeping
West Coast Goalkeeping uses three tiers, Core, Elite and Pro, with cashback that rises from 5% to 7% to 10% based on spend over a rolling 12 months. Elite starts at about $150 and Pro at about $200, which the brand set from how its repeat customers buy: two or three orders to reach Elite and three to five to reach Pro. Pro members also get free upgraded shipping, applied automatically at checkout. The thresholds are low on purpose, so the top tier is within reach of anyone who shops regularly. Read the West Coast Goalkeeping case study.
Youswim
Youswim's program, The Tide, pays store credit instead of points. Members earn 5% back, and three tiers, Sand, Sea and Sky, raise it to 7% at $250 of spend over a rolling year and 10% at $500. Higher tiers add a bigger birthday reward, early access to sales and launches, free expedited shipping, free returns and exchanges, and a free gift at the top. It launched in August 2026, so there are no results to report yet. Read the Youswim case study.
Love Sweat Fitness and Gelato Pique
Love Sweat Fitness runs Feel Good Rewards with four VIP tiers: Bronze Babe, Silver Star, Golden Girl and Diamond Darling. Members earn 1 point per dollar, and the points multiplier rises from 1x up to 1.75x as they move up. Higher tiers add a richer birthday reward, member-only discounts, early access to new products and sales, and first access to the founder's Town Hall. Its case study reports 2x member lifetime value and 82% higher purchase frequency than non-members.
Gelato Pique runs The Pique Club with three VIP tiers: Dreamer, Lover and VIP Sleeper. Members earn 10 points per dollar, get a coupon the moment they reach a new tier, and earn a bigger multiplier on every order after that, up to 1.5x at the top. Gift reminders give customers a reason to return outside their own buying cycle. Its case study reports 22.7% higher member AOV and 67.8% higher member lifetime value than non-members.
Tiered loyalty program mistakes
Not giving customers enough reason to reach the next tier
The mistake I see most is a tier that does not motivate. If the reward for reaching a level is too small to notice, customers do not change what they buy to get there, and the tier becomes a label. Make each level worth reaching, then keep the first one within reach: a threshold built from instinct can leave customers stranded in the base tier. Use your own order data and purchase intervals so a meaningful share of customers has a credible next step.
Benefits customers cannot see
Do not bury status in a generic account page. Customers need to see what they have, what they can earn next and how much progress remains.
Discounts that reward behavior that would have happened anyway
A deeper discount can cut margin without changing behavior. Test access, recognition, shipping upgrades and exclusive products before increasing discount depth, and review results by tier, not only across all members. Our guide to points versus tiers covers when each structure fits.
No policy for refunds, expiry or downgrades
Returns affect qualification. If tier entry is based on spend, refunded orders should not permanently inflate status. Decide the status window before launch, explain it plainly and tell customers before a downgrade. Protection options and advance notice give a soft landing, and surprise status changes create support work.
How to launch and measure a tiered program
Define one business objective, qualify on spend, choose two to four tiers, set thresholds from your own order data, pick a status window and decide what protection to offer. Test the thresholds against real order history before you publish, then make the benefit table and a progress indicator visible in the account, on product pages, in email and after purchase. After launch, review progression, repeat purchase rate, AOV, redemption, reward cost and margin by tier, and revisit thresholds every quarter. For a wider look at what tiers sit inside, see our guide to VIP loyalty programs.
Frequently asked questions
What is a tiered loyalty program?
A tiered loyalty program is a structure where customers move through levels based on spend, points, orders or another measurable behavior. Each level provides better benefits, such as a higher earn rate, free shipping, early access or exclusive rewards.
How does a tiered loyalty program work?
A store sets what qualifies a customer, defines thresholds, assigns customers to tiers and delivers benefits for each tier. It also needs rules for how long status lasts, what happens when a customer falls short, and how refunds are handled.
How many tiers should a loyalty program have?
Two to four tiers, including a base tier. Of the 34 programs we compared, 33 use two to four and 31 use three or four.
What should loyalty tiers be based on?
I recommend spend. Across the 34 programs, 18 qualify on spend, 15 on points and 1 on order count, and several points programs are effectively spend because they award 1 point per $1.
Should loyalty tiers reset every year?
Not necessarily. I prefer a rolling 12-month window so customers keep spending to keep their tier. A calendar year also works if you protect status for a year, so a customer who upgrades in December does not lose the tier a few days later. In the 34 programs, 15 use a fixed year, 12 use an individual 12-month clock and 14 carry a tier through the following year.
Where should the first paid tier start?
If your data is thin, just above your average order value, with the next tier at roughly twice AOV. Across the programs that publish dollar thresholds, the first step runs from $20 to $751, and most sit between $100 and $500.
Do tiers work for every brand?
No. I would skip them when a brand does not want customers to feel excluded, when purchase frequency is unpredictable, when prices range from a few dollars to thousands, when customers buy about once a year or less, or when the product line is very small. It is situational. In those cases a flat store credit rate, a wishlist and personal recognition usually fit better than tiers.
Can Shopify support tiered loyalty programs?
Shopify holds the customer and order data, and a loyalty app such as Mage manages tier rules, benefits, progress displays and rewards. Mage supports spend, points and order-based entry, three status windows and optional tier protection.
Build the first version around spend, two to four tiers and benefits customers will notice. If a tier does not give customers a reason to come back sooner, simplify the structure before adding another level.
I'm Kris, co-founder of Mage Loyalty. I spend most days talking to merchants and making sure our customers get real results. We work with Shopify brands, retailers and restaurants, so if that's you (or you're an agency working with them), we should chat!

















