Meet Mage AIDiscover

Best Shopify Loyalty App for Small Business in 2027: 6 Compared on Cost

Written by
Graeme
Graeme
Co-Founder
Reading time
14 min read
Last updated
November 11, 2026
Best Shopify Loyalty App for Small Business in 2027: 6 Compared on Cost

This list compares six Shopify loyalty apps for a small store: what each costs at 500, 1,000 and 2,500 orders a month, how big its free plan is, and which features sit behind the cheaper plans. It is written for a store that is deciding between a free plan, a $15 plan and a plan with VIP tiers. We make Mage Loyalty, so it is one of the six and you should read its section with that in mind. Prices and plan details were read from each vendor's pricing page and Shopify listing on 11 November 2026 (Mage's on 1 November 2026); hands-on notes appear only for Smile.io, Rivo, BON Loyalty and Growave, the apps our owners have run, and for the other two the evidence is published pricing and documentation.

What We Looked At

  • Cost at your order volume. Most apps price by monthly orders, so a headline price means little until you put it next to 500, 1,000 or 2,500 orders.
  • What the cheap plans include. VIP tiers, bonus point campaigns, a loyalty page and store credit are often held back for a higher plan, and that gate is usually where a $15 plan becomes a $129 or $199 plan.
  • How big the free plan is. A free plan only helps while your orders stay under its cap, and its cap ranges from 100 to 250 orders a month.
  • What happens at the limit. Some apps bill per extra order, some stop a feature, and some ask you to upgrade.

The list is ordered by the first two factors together: the monthly bill at 500 orders and at 1,000 orders for the cheapest plan that includes VIP tiers, added together, with the cost at 2,500 orders breaking ties. We use VIP tiers as the yardstick because it is the feature that most often moves a store from a $15 plan to a much dearer one. On that measure Mage Loyalty comes first, because VIP tiers start on its $49 plan. Mage is not the cheapest at 1,000 orders, where BON Loyalty and Joy Loyalty are $20 cheaper, and by 2,500 orders only Rivo costs more of the six. Rivo is second, BON Loyalty and Joy Loyalty are level on the 500 and 1,000 order total and are split by their 2,500 order cost, and Smile.io and Growave are level and are split the same way. This is our judgment against those criteria, not a test result.

Yotpo is left out because its entry paid plan is $199 a month for 500 orders and does not include VIP tiers, which need Premium, a plan Yotpo quotes on request, so a VIP-inclusive price cannot be calculated for it.

“Great app! User friendly and straightforward. The customer service team has been great and so helpful.”
Jenn
Jenn
Founder, Skynbio
SKYNBIO

Read the SKYNBIO case study →

Comparison of the Best Shopify Loyalty Apps for Small Businesses

AppFree planCheapest paid planVIP tiers fromShopify App Store rating, read 11 November 2026
Mage LoyaltyNoEssential, $15 (500 orders)Starter, $495 out of 5
RivoYes, 200 ordersEssentials, $15 (500 orders)Scale, $494.7 from 1,441 reviews
BON LoyaltyYes, 150 ordersStarter, $15 (300 orders)Growth, $1295.0 from 1,987 reviews
Joy LoyaltyYes, 250 ordersEssential, $29 (500 orders)Advanced, $1294.9 from 1,788 reviews
Smile.ioYes, 200 ordersEssential, $15 (500 orders)Growth, $1994.9 from 4,673 reviews
GrowaveYes, 200 orders on the listing, 100 on the pricing pageEntry, $15 (500 orders)Growth, $1994.8 from 1,287 reviews

Prices checked 11 November 2026 on each vendor's pricing page and Shopify listing, and 1 November 2026 for Mage. Plan names are the vendors' own. Growave's pages disagree on its free plan cap, so both figures are shown.

What a Small Store Pays at 500, 1,000 and 2,500 Orders

The first table shows the cheapest plan that covers each volume, whatever it includes. The second shows the cheapest plan with VIP tiers, which is the one used to order this list. Figures marked "est." are our calculation from each vendor's published allowance and overage rate, with the working shown below; the rest are list prices.

Cheapest plan that covers the volume

App500 orders1,000 orders2,500 orders
Mage Loyalty$15 (Essential, list)$149 est. (Starter)$449 est. (Starter)
Rivo$15 (Essentials, list)$169 est. (Scale)$469 est. (Scale)
BON Loyalty$29 (Basic, list)$129 (Growth, list)$129 (Growth, list)
Joy Loyalty$29 (Essential, list)$104 est. (Essential)$179 est. (Advanced)
Smile.io$15 (Essential, list)$79 (Standard, list)$199 (Growth, list)
Growave$15 (Entry, list)$115 (Entry, list)$349 (Growth, list)

Cheapest plan with VIP tiers

App500 orders1,000 orders2,500 orders
Mage Loyalty$49 (Starter, list)$149 est.$449 est.
Rivo$69 est. (Scale)$169 est.$469 est.
BON Loyalty$129 (Growth, list)$129 (list)$129 (list)
Joy Loyalty$129 (Advanced, list)$129 (list)$179 est.
Smile.io$199 (Growth, list)$199 (list)$199 (list)
Growave$199 (Growth, list)$199 (list)$349 (list)

Working for the estimates, using each vendor's published rates:

  • Mage Loyalty: Starter is $49 including 500 orders, then $0.20 per extra order. At 1,000 orders that is $49 + 500 × $0.20 = $149, and at 2,500 it is $49 + 2,000 × $0.20 = $449. Growth is $499 and includes 2,500 orders. Essential has no listed overage rate, so it is not calculated above 500 orders.
  • Rivo: the Shopify listing says Scale is $49 including 400 orders, then $20 per 100 more. At 500 orders that is $49 + 1 × $20 = $69, at 1,000 it is $49 + 6 × $20 = $169, and at 2,500 it is $49 + 21 × $20 = $469. Rivo's in-app plans screen and pricing page do not repeat the 400-order figure.
  • Joy Loyalty: Essential is $29 including 500 orders, then $15 per 100, so 1,000 orders is $29 + 5 × $15 = $104. Advanced is $129 including 2,000 orders, then $10 per 100, so 2,500 orders is $129 + 5 × $10 = $179.
  • Smile.io, BON Loyalty and Growave: every figure is a list price or comes straight from the vendor's own price table. Growave's help centre prices 901 to 1,000 orders on Entry at $115 and 2,401 to 2,500 on Growth at $349.

These figures cover the loyalty plan only. They leave out Rivo's separate Cashback and Accounts products, Mage's paid modules, and any annual-billing discount. They assume every order counts and volume is steady month to month; the apps count orders differently (for example, BON and Smile.io count refunded orders, and Growave does not).

Mage Loyalty: Lowest Price for VIP Tiers, but No Free Plan and a Bill That Climbs With Orders

Mage Loyalty, which we make, has Essential at $15 a month and Starter at $49, both including 500 orders, Growth at $499 including 2,500 orders, and Enterprise by quote (Mage's pricing page, checked 1 November 2026). The gate that matters for a small store is VIP tiers: they start on Starter at $49, not on Essential. Starter also adds wishlists, Shopify POS and bonus point campaigns, and Mage lists up to 10 VIP tiers. Orders above the allowance cost $0.20 each on Starter and $0.15 on Growth, so Starter is $49 at 500 orders, an estimated $149 at 1,000 and an estimated $449 at 2,500. Starter and Growth have a 7-day free trial.

Best for: a store at around 500 orders a month that wants VIP tiers, a wishlist and Shopify POS for $49, which is the lowest price for VIP tiers in this list.

Where it falls short: there is no free plan, and the per-order overage means the bill grows faster than BON's or Joy's: at 1,000 orders they are $20 cheaper, and at 2,500 only Rivo costs more of the six. Mage is also the newest app here, on the Shopify App Store since 21 March 2025 without a Built for Shopify badge, and it lists 20 integrations (1 November 2026). See the Mage Loyalty pricing page and VIP tiers on Shopify.

Rivo: Second-Cheapest Way to VIP Tiers, With a Free Plan and a $15 Plan

Rivo has a Free plan for up to 200 orders, Essentials at $15 for up to 500, Scale at $49 and Plus at $499 for up to 2,500 orders. VIP tiers, bonus campaigns and store credit programs start on Scale; Essentials adds birthday rewards and Shopify POS integration. On the Shopify listing Scale includes 400 orders for $49 and then charges $20 per 100, which makes it an estimated $69 at 500 orders, $169 at 1,000 and $469 at 2,500. The in-app plans screen is shown below.

Rivo in-app plans screen showing Essentials at $15 a month for up to 500 monthly orders, Scale at $49 a month with a pay as you go order slider, and Plus at $499 a month for up to 2,500 monthly orders, with a risk-free trial and money-back guarantee note. Taken 2 November 2026.

Graeme, our co-founder, wrote: "I had a working program and widget in about 15 minutes. That is a floor rather than a typical figure, because it depends on how much you build."

Best for: a store of 200 to about 1,000 orders that wants VIP tiers for $69 to $169.

Where it falls short: Essentials stops at 500 orders, so a growing store jumps to Scale, whose 400 included orders appear only on the listing. Rivo has no Built for Shopify badge, its wishlist sits inside a separate Accounts product from $499 a month, and Graeme's note is: "The admin is consistent and easy to find your way around, but it feels dated, and the storefront widget does the job without looking as modern as some alternatives." It is rated 4.7 from 1,441 reviews. See our Rivo review.

BON Loyalty: Fixed $129 for Unlimited Orders, With VIP Tiers Only From That Plan

BON Loyalty has a Free plan for 150 orders, Starter at $15 for 300, Basic at $29 for 500, and Growth at $129 with unlimited orders. Growth is the only self-serve plan above 500 orders and the first with VIP tiers, so BON costs $129 at 500, 1,000 and 2,500 orders alike, or $103 a month when billed annually per its pricing page. Basic adds Shopify POS and analytics; Starter adds points expiry and a dedicated loyalty page. BON's listing shows a Built for Shopify badge and 5.0 from 1,987 reviews.

Graeme's note in our rewards apps roundup is that "the interface feels older and clunkier than the newer apps here", meaning the other apps in that list.

Best for: a store heading above 1,000 orders a month that wants VIP tiers, because $129 does not rise with volume and is the lowest VIP-tier price in this list at 2,500 orders.

Where it falls short: VIP tiers are $129 even at 500 orders, more than double Mage's $49 and close to double Rivo's estimated $69. There is no overage, but BON's docs say that at the monthly limit the Complete an Order earning action and the referral program stop generating points. Store credit, gift card rewards and wishlists are not listed. Read our BON Loyalty review.

Joy Loyalty: Biggest Free Plan, and VIP Tiers With 2,000 Orders Included for $129

Joy Loyalty has the largest free plan in this list: Starter is $0 for 250 orders a month with points, a loyalty widget and a referral program with a cap of 30. It leaves out birthday, review and survey actions, free-shipping and free-product rewards, points expiration and a dedicated loyalty page. Essential is $29 for 500 orders, then $15 per 100; Advanced is $129 for 2,000, then $10 per 100. VIP tiers, paid membership, Shopify POS and bonus point campaigns start on Advanced. The Earning programs tab, shown below, marks some features "Available on Advanced".

Joy Loyalty Reward programs page on the Earning programs tab: Place Order earns 1 point for every $1, with Sign Up (250 points), Birthday Reward (500 points) and a Facebook follow reward (50 points) listed as active, each with a Turn off button, and an Instagram Comment Rewards banner marked New and Available on Advanced. Taken November 2026.

Best for: a store under 250 orders that wants a free start, or one at 1,000 to 2,000 orders that wants VIP tiers at $129 with 2,000 orders included, which is $179 at 2,500 orders.

Where it falls short: Joy raised its Essential and Advanced prices for new subscribers on 9 February 2026, from $24.90 to $29 and from $99 to $129, and its help centre says existing subscribers kept the old rates. Wishlists are a separate Joy app and Starter asks you to upgrade past 250 orders. Our owners have not published hands-on notes for Joy. It is rated 4.9 from 1,788 reviews, with a Built for Shopify badge. See our Joy Loyalty review.

Smile.io: Easiest First Program, but VIP Tiers Start at $199

Smile.io has a Free plan for up to 200 orders, Essential at $15 for 500, Standard at $79 for 1,000, Growth at $199 for 2,500 orders then $20 per 100, and Plus at $999 billed annually. Points and referrals are on every plan including Free; free-product rewards start on Essential, bonus points events on Standard, and VIP tiers and points expiry on Growth. A store pays $15 at 500 orders and $79 at 1,000, but $199 once it wants VIP tiers. Its listing shows 4.9 from 4,673 reviews and a Built for Shopify badge. The Points page, shown below, keeps the earning rule and the reward on one screen.

Smile.io admin Points page: one earning rule (5 points per $1 spent), one reward (100 points = $1 off), and a points delay option marked as available on the Growth plan and above. Taken 31 October 2026.

Graeme, our co-founder, wrote of Smile.io: "Setup took under ten minutes. The app opens inside the Shopify admin, so navigation and layout match what a merchant already uses, and earning rules and rewards sit on a single Points page, with Referrals, VIP, Activity and Bonus Campaigns as sibling tabs."

Best for: a store under 1,000 orders that wants points and referrals without VIP tiers, at $15 to $79.

Where it falls short: VIP tiers cost about four times Mage's entry price for them, the Free plan has no analytics page or dedicated loyalty page and shows Smile's branding and wishlists are not listed. Read our Smile.io review.

Growave: Loyalty, Reviews and Wishlist in One App From $15

Growave bundles loyalty, native reviews and a wishlist, and its $15 plan lists a wishlist and photo reviews, which none of the other five lists at that price. Entry is $15 for 500 orders and then $20 per extra 100 up to a documented maximum of 1,500 orders at $215; Growth is $199 for 1,500 orders and then $15 per 100; VIP tiers, store credit, gift cards, points expiration and video reviews start on Growth; checkout extensions and the API start on Plus. That makes it $115 at 1,000 orders on Entry, $199 for VIP tiers at 500 or 1,000, and $349 at 2,500. The listing shows 4.8 from 1,287 reviews and a Built for Shopify badge.

Graeme's published note is: "the UI is old and clunky, but it has the full suite."

Best for: a store under about 1,000 orders that would otherwise run a separate reviews or wishlist app, because Entry covers all three for $15 to $115.

Where it falls short: VIP tiers need the $199 Growth plan, and Entry costs $215 at 1,500 orders, more than Growth's $199 base. Entry includes one integration, Growave's help centre says widgets stop working when the Free plan limit is reached, and its pages give two different Free caps, 100 and 200 orders. See our Growave review.

How to Choose a Loyalty App for Your Small Store

  • Under 250 orders a month and no budget: start on a free plan. Joy's is the largest at 250 orders, then Smile.io and Rivo at 200, then BON at 150. Check what the free plan leaves out first: Joy's has no loyalty page, and Smile.io's has no analytics page.
  • About 500 orders, points and referrals only: $15 buys that on Smile.io, Rivo and Growave, and on Mage's Essential plan; BON and Joy charge $29. Choose Growave if you also want reviews and a wishlist.
  • 500 to 1,000 orders and you want VIP tiers: compare Mage ($49 to an estimated $149), Rivo ($69 to $169 est.), and BON and Joy ($129). Mage is cheapest at 500 orders and BON and Joy at 1,000.
  • 1,000 to 2,500 orders and growing: BON's $129 for unlimited orders and Joy's $179 est. at 2,500 are the cheapest; Smile.io's $199 covers 2,500 orders. Mage and Rivo cost more at this size.
  • Moving from another app: Mage offers free managed migration, Smile.io and Growave import points by CSV, and BON's support team imports a CSV for you. See our guide to moving from Smile.io without losing points.
  • Still comparing two apps: read Smile.io vs Rivo or Joy Loyalty vs Smile.io, the Smile.io alternatives page, the Rivo alternatives page, or the wider Shopify rewards apps roundup. For setting a budget, see how to budget for a loyalty program.

Install two or three and click around before you commit: the admin you prefer is a personal call.

Frequently Asked Questions

What is the best loyalty app for a small Shopify business?

It depends on your order volume. For a store at 500 orders that wants VIP tiers, Mage Loyalty, which we make, is the cheapest at $49. At 1,000 orders, BON Loyalty and Joy Loyalty cost $129. For a free start, Joy's plan covers 250 orders. This ranking is our judgment against cost, not a test.

What is the cheapest loyalty program software for small business?

A free plan is cheapest: Joy at 250 orders, Smile.io and Rivo at 200, and BON at 150. For paid plans, $15 a month buys 500 orders on Smile.io, Rivo, Growave and Mage Essential, or 300 on BON Starter. Cheapest for VIP tiers is Mage Starter at $49. Prices checked 11 November 2026, Mage's 1 November 2026.

Is there a free loyalty app for Shopify?

Yes, for small volumes. Joy Loyalty, Smile.io, Rivo, BON Loyalty and Growave all list a free plan, with caps of 250, 200, 200, 150 and 100 or 200 orders a month respectively. None of the free plans include VIP tiers, and Mage has no free plan. Check each free plan's gaps before installing.

How much does a Shopify loyalty app cost at 500 and 1,000 orders a month?

At 500 orders, $15 on Smile.io, Rivo, Growave and Mage, or $29 on BON and Joy. At 1,000 orders, $79 on Smile.io, an estimated $104 on Joy, $115 on Growave, $129 on BON, an estimated $149 on Mage and an estimated $169 on Rivo. VIP tiers raise some of these prices.

What happens when a small store passes its order limit?

It varies by app. Smile.io says the program keeps working and asks you to review your plan; BON stops the Complete an Order earning action and the referral program from generating points; Joy's paid plans bill per extra order; Growave's help centre says widgets stop working at the Free plan limit. Rivo's pages do not say.

Can I switch loyalty apps without losing points?

Usually. Mage offers free managed migration with importers for Yotpo, Smile.io and LoyaltyLion, and a typical go-live of 1 to 2 weeks; earning rules and rewards are not imported. Other apps move points by CSV, and Growave's CSV import covers points, VIP tier status and birthdays. Check balances and tiers after any import.

Ready to see Mage in action? Book a demo.

About the author
Graeme

Graeme

Co-Founder

Graeme is the co-founder at Mage Loyalty. He heads product development, from complex loyalty migrations and large-scale data handling to building the features shaping the future of loyalty.

Build a loyalty experience your customers remember.

See how modern Shopify brands use Mage to build stronger customer relationships and drive repeat revenue.

Trusted by
  • Reelie
  • Gelato Pique
  • MiaDonna
  • Tea Drops
  • West Coast Goalkeeping
  • Joy Dravecky
  • Love Sweat Fitness
  • The GoTo
  • Youswim

Related articles

Customer Acquisition Cost (CAC): Formula, Guide & Examples: a minimalist cinematic landscape with the title in the sky
Guides & Tips

Customer Acquisition Cost (CAC): Formula, Guide & Examples

Here is the most expensive belief in ecommerce finance: that a lower customer acquisition cost is always better. It sounds obvious. Spend less to win a customer, keep more profit. But that instinct quietly bankrupts brands, because customer acquisition cost (CAC) is meaningless on its own. A $10 CAC is a disaster if each customer is only worth $10. A $500 CAC is a gift if each customer returns $4,000. CAC only tells you anything when you set it next to what a customer is actually worth.

White text reading “How Much Does a Loyalty Program Cost” on a soft gradient background.
Loyalty & Retention

How Much Does a Loyalty Program Cost to Maintain Each Year?

A loyalty program annual cost can run far beyond the subscription. One commercial software guide estimated $39,000 to $64,000 before custom development and ongoing maintenance. For Shopify merchants, the useful question is narrower: what will your program cost to run this year, and how much incremental contribution margin must it generate to earn that budget back?

Minimalist landscape with article title "Cost Per Retained Customer: The Metric That Should Sit Next to CAC" displayed in the
Loyalty & Retention

Cost Per Retained Customer: The Metric That Should Sit Next to CAC

Shopify store owners that fail to measure Cost Per Retained Customer often leave 25-95% of potential profit gains on the table, even while driving strong acquisition numbers.

Hiker on a coastal cliff path with a palm leaf in the foreground, with the words “Best Shopify Referral Apps” in spaced capitals
Loyalty & Retention

The 7 Best Shopify Referral Apps for 2027 (Compared)

Most Shopify store owners don't realize that referral programs generate 4x higher conversion rates than traditional advertising, yet they still operate referral campaigns as an afterthought rather than a core growth lever. The difference between stores scaling to seven figures and those stuck at mid-six isn't the quality of their product—it's how systematically they turn customers into salespeople.

Best Shopify Loyalty Apps with Store Credit Functionality
Loyalty & Retention

Best Shopify Loyalty Apps for Store Credit: 6 Compared (2027)

Six Shopify loyalty apps compared on whether they run rewards as store credit or only issue it as a reward, which plan it starts on, whose balance it is, cashback pricing and expiry. Prices checked November 2026.

Logos of Mage, Smile.io, BON Loyalty, Okendo, Rivo, Growave, Yotpo and LoyaltyLion on frosted glass tiles over a lavender gradient
Loyalty & Retention

Best Shopify Rewards Apps in 2027: 8 Loyalty Apps Compared

Eight Shopify loyalty and rewards apps compared on price, what each plan includes and how they feel to run, with hands-on notes and prices checked 11 November 2026 (Mage’s on 1 November 2026).