Meet Mage AIDiscover

Lingerie Rewards Programs Compared: Cost, Earn Rate, Tiers and Perks at Five Brands

Written by
Graeme
Graeme
Co-Founder
Reading time
10 min read
Date posted
November 22, 2026
Logos for ThirdLove, Real Rewards by American Eagle and Aerie, Victoria's Secret and PINK Rewards, Eberjey and Savage X Fenty on frosted glass tiles over a flat peach background

This round-up compares the rewards programs of five lingerie and intimates brands (ThirdLove, Aerie, Victoria's Secret, Eberjey and Savage X Fenty), and the best one depends on how often you buy. ThirdLove gives the highest published return without a store credit card, up to 10% back from Platinum. Aerie suits steady shoppers who buy across two brands, Eberjey suits anyone who would rather have early access than money off, and Savage X Fenty is the only program that charges a monthly fee. Victoria's Secret has the lowest base return at 2.5%, so its value sits in the perks and the card.

Last checked on 21 November 2026 against each brand's own program page, for the US in US dollars. Each program has a full breakdown, linked below.

This guide is written by Graeme, co-founder of Mage, a loyalty and customer accounts platform for Shopify.

What decides which lingerie rewards program is worth joining

Five factors separate these programs, and the comparison below follows them in order.

  • Cost. Four of the five are free to join. Savage X Fenty charges $69.95 a month in the US, and nothing in a month you skip.
  • What you get back. Where a program uses points, the return per $1 is the number to compare: 5% to 10% at ThirdLove, 4% to 8% at Aerie and 2.5% at Victoria's Secret before any card. Eberjey and Savage X Fenty have no points, so there is no rate to compare.
  • How fast the better perks arrive. Spend thresholds run from $200 to $1,000 in a calendar year, except at Savage X Fenty, which has none.
  • Perks a lingerie shopper uses. Free shipping, a birthday reward, a stylist and early access are the ones the brands actually offer.
  • Where it works, and any card layer. All five run in the US, Eberjey covers the continental US only, and Aerie also takes members in Canada. Aerie and Victoria's Secret each add a store credit card level on top of the free program.

Lingerie rewards programs compared side by side

ProgramCostEarn rateWhat a point is worthTiers (count and top threshold)Standout perkFull breakdown
ThirdLove Hooked RewardsFreeOne point per $1, doubled at Platinum$0.05: 5% back, 10% at Platinum (our arithmetic)2, Platinum at $250 a yearA quarterly free pair of underwear (with a purchase over $35) and a VIP stylist at PlatinumHow Hooked Rewards works
Aerie Real RewardsFree10, 15 or 20 points per $1, 40 with the store card$0.004: 4% back at Level 1 up to 8% at Level 3, 16% with the card3 spend levels plus a card level, Level 3 at $500 a yearFree shipping from $25 and free returns at Level 3How Real Rewards works
Victoria's Secret and PINK RewardsFree5 points per $1 at every tier, 10 or 15 for cardmembers$0.005: 2.5% back (our arithmetic)3, Gold at $750 a yearA yearly Pick Your Perk at GoldHow Victoria's Secret and PINK Rewards works
Eberjey loyalty programFreeNo points, spend moves you upNo points3, Tier 3 at $1,000 a yearEarly access and pre-orders from Tier 2How Eberjey's loyalty program works
Savage X Fenty Rewards Membership$69.95 a month, free to skipNo points, 2 Member Credits per billingEach credit covers one item or set worth up to $50NoneA free underwear pack or bra on every fifth billingHow Savage X Fenty's membership works

ThirdLove Hooked Rewards: best for shoppers who will pass $250 a year

Hooked Rewards is best for a shopper who expects to spend $250 in a calendar year, because that is the line where Platinum starts and the earn rate doubles from 1 to 2 points per $1. With 100 points worth $5, that turns 5% back into 10% (our arithmetic), the highest figure here without a store card. Platinum also adds free shipping on every order, a free pair of underwear each quarter with a purchase over $35, and a VIP stylist, so someone who wants fit help gets a named service alongside the discount. Gold members still get free shipping from $75 and early access to sales.

The Gold and Platinum benefits table on ThirdLove's Rewards page as of 28 October 2026.
Perks and Benefits table on the Hooked Rewards page comparing Gold and Platinum: points per purchase, free shipping, birthday gift, anniversary gift, sale early access, free undies every quarter, members-only sales and VIP stylist

The Gold and Platinum benefits table on ThirdLove's Rewards page as of 28 October 2026.

The drawbacks are the clock and the reach. Points lapse a year after they are issued, Platinum has to be earned again each year, and the program is open to US residents only. See how ThirdLove's Hooked Rewards works for the full picture, or start from ThirdLove's own rewards page.

Aerie Real Rewards: best for steady shoppers at American Eagle and Aerie

Real Rewards is best for someone who buys at both American Eagle and Aerie, because one membership earns across the two, joining needs no purchase, and the return starts at 4% and climbs with annual spending. Level 2 begins at $200 a year and pays 6% back, Level 3 begins at $500 and pays 8%. Free shipping gets easier as you rise, with the minimum falling from $75 to $50 to $25, and free returns arrive at Level 3. Every level gets a $5 birthday reward. A store credit card sits above the levels at 16% back, and it is a credit product with its own terms.

The levels table on the Real Rewards page as of 28 October 2026.
Real Rewards levels table: Level 1 free at 4% back and 10 points per $1, Level 2 at $200 a year and 6% back, Level 3 at $500 a year and 8% back, and Credit Cardmember at 16% back, with free shipping, birthday reward and members-only perks

The levels table on the Real Rewards page as of 28 October 2026.

The drawbacks are the deadlines. Rewards arrive automatically and last only 60 days, and a year with no qualifying purchase (375 days) wipes the whole points balance. A shopper who buys now and then also sits at the 4% level, where the first $5 reward takes $125 of spending. Read how Aerie's Real Rewards works, or go straight to the Real Rewards page.

Victoria's Secret and PINK Rewards: best for occasional shoppers who value perks over rate

This program suits an occasional shopper who joins before the first order and wants shipping and birthday perks more than a high return. The reason is the math: 5 points per $1 and a $10 reward per 2,000 points is 2.5% back at every tier, so climbing to Silver ($300 a year) or Gold ($750) changes the perks and not the rate. Those perks are a lower free shipping minimum online ($50, then $25 at Gold), two 2x Points Days a year from Silver, a yearly Pick Your Perk at Gold and a $10 birthday reward. Cardmembers earn 10 or 15 points per $1, which is 5% to 7.5% (our arithmetic).

The tier benefits on the Rewards page as of 28 October 2026.
Program benefits table: Member with no minimum spend, Silver at $300 or more and Gold at $750 or more, with 5 points per $1, $50 and $25 free shipping, a $10 birthday reward, 2x Points Days and Pick Your Perk

The tier benefits on the Rewards page as of 28 October 2026.

The drawbacks are the low base rate and the short windows. One $10 reward takes $400 of spending, points lapse a year after earning, and a reward is good for 90 days. Purchases before you join earn nothing. How Victoria's Secret and PINK Rewards works covers the detail, and the brand's own page is its Rewards page.

Eberjey loyalty program: best for shoppers who want access more than discounts

Eberjey's program suits a shopper who values being first, because it has no points and pays in access. A member moves up on spend, with Tier 2 starting at $300 and Tier 3 at $1,000 a year. Tier 2 brings early access, pre-orders and in-store events, and Tier 3 adds Express 2-day shipping and VIP events. The 20% birthday offer applies in your birthday month at every tier, so even a once-a-year buyer gets one concrete reward.

Eberjey's tier table as of 28 October 2026.
Eberjey loyalty tiers: Tier 1 for members, Tier 2 from $300 spent and Tier 3 from $1000 spent, with the benefits ticked for each tier

Eberjey's tier table as of 28 October 2026.

The drawbacks come from how the year works. Status resets every January 1 and benefits expire on December 31, so a late-year climb leaves little time to use the perks. Returns deduct their spend and can drop a tier. The shipping perk is a speed upgrade on orders that would already ship free, and Eberjey publishes no dollar value for most perks. It covers the continental US only. Learn how Eberjey's loyalty program works, or see Eberjey's loyalty page.

Savage X Fenty Rewards Membership: best for shoppers happy to pay for credits

This is the one paid program in the group, and it suits someone who buys sets or higher priced pieces regularly. The reason is that the fee buys credits, not entry: $69.95 is charged on the 6th and gives 2 Member Credits, each good for an item or set worth up to $50, or two together for one worth up to $100. Skipping in the first five days of the month costs nothing and member pricing stays. Members also get 90-day returns against 30 days for guests, and a free underwear pack or bra on every fifth billing.

The Member Credits section of the Savage X Fenty Rewards Membership page, as of 28 October 2026.
Savage X Fenty Member Credits section: 2 Member Credits per $69.95 billing, with a value ladder of 1 credit for an item or set up to $50, 2 credits up to $100 and 3 credits up to $150

The Member Credits section of the Savage X Fenty Rewards Membership page, as of 28 October 2026.

The drawbacks are the manual skip and the expiry. The charge lands automatically unless you skip each month, the fee is nonrefundable apart from one case, and credits expire 12 months after issue. There are no points or tiers. How Savage X Fenty's membership works explains the billing, and the brand is at savagex.com.

Which lingerie rewards program is worth joining?

A frequent buyer at one brand. ThirdLove, if you will pass $250 a year, because the rate doubles to 10% and Platinum adds shipping and a stylist. Aerie, if your wardrobe also comes from American Eagle, because spending at both counts toward Level 3 at 8% back with free shipping from $25.

An occasional buyer. Join Eberjey or Aerie before your first order. Eberjey pays a 20% birthday offer at every tier, and Aerie pays a $5 birthday reward at every level, so a one-order-a-year shopper still gets something. Aerie points survive as long as you make one purchase a year.

Someone who wants fit help. ThirdLove Platinum, because its VIP stylist is the only styling perk built into any of the five programs, and it needs $250 of yearly spend.

Someone who likes a monthly credit. Savage X Fenty, because two credits cover an item or set up to $100 and skipping a month is free. Set a reminder for the 5th, since the charge is automatic.

Someone who wants early access. Eberjey from Tier 2, because pre-orders and early access are the main benefit and need only $300 a year.

What lingerie brands can learn from these five programs

Four of the five programs are free, and the one that charges treats the fee as prepaid credit. Beyond cost, three design choices show up across the group.

Tiers either change the rate or change the perks. ThirdLove and Aerie raise the earn rate as spend rises, so the step is visible in the return. Victoria's Secret keeps 5 points per $1 at every tier and differentiates on shipping, bonus days and an annual pick, and Eberjey has no points. A flat rate is simpler to explain, but it gives members little reason to climb unless the perks are worth wanting.

Clocks bring members back, if they are easy to state. Aerie rewards last 60 days and Victoria's Secret rewards last 90. Expiry rules differ too: inactivity at Aerie, a year at ThirdLove and Victoria's Secret, a January reset at Eberjey. A vanishing balance frustrates members, so the rule should fit on one line.

Shared programs and store cards lift the top return. Aerie and Victoria's Secret each run one program across two brands and add a card layer.

Mage tiers can be based on spend, points earned or order count. Progress can follow the calendar year, a rolling twelve months or lifetime, and each tier can add a points multiplier or its own rewards. Expiry is off unless you switch it on, and it then counts either from the day points are earned or from the customer's last purchase, with a reminder email beforehand. If you are building a VIP tier program on Shopify, those settings cover the tier designs above. A paid membership program on Shopify uses Mage Memberships, an Enterprise module with monthly, quarterly or annual billing. Our guide to fashion loyalty program examples covers ten more brands.

The Shopify loyalty program growing brands trust

See how Mage helps Shopify brands lift repeat purchase rate with loyalty, referrals and store credit.

Book a demo
“Cannot say enough good things about the team at Mage Loyalty, one of the absolute best organizations we have ever worked with, full stop! So glad we connected with them, completely redid our loyalty program, new concepts, use of loyalty, increasing user engagement, showing us where we were not valuing our best customers, just WOW, amazing team!”
Shawn Norris
Shawn Norris
Founder, West Coast Goalkeeping
West Coast Goalkeeping

Read the West Coast Goalkeeping case study →

Frequently asked questions

Which lingerie rewards program gives the most back? ThirdLove's Platinum tier, at 10% back, is the highest published return without a store credit card, ahead of Aerie's 8% at Level 3 and Victoria's Secret's 2.5% base rate (our arithmetic for ThirdLove and Victoria's Secret). For cardmembers, Aerie's card is 16% back and Victoria's Secret's card is 5% to 7.5%, with more on bras (our arithmetic).

Do any lingerie brands charge for their rewards program? Savage X Fenty does: $69.95 a month in the US, with nothing charged in a month you skip by the 5th. ThirdLove, Aerie, Victoria's Secret and Eberjey are free to join.

Which lingerie rewards programs have tiers? Four of the five. ThirdLove has two, with Platinum at $250 a year. Aerie has three spend levels plus a card level, with Level 3 at $500. Victoria's Secret has three, with Gold at $750, and Eberjey has three, with Tier 3 at $1,000. Savage X Fenty has none.

Do lingerie rewards points expire? Yes, in different ways. ThirdLove points expire 12 months after issue and Victoria's Secret points 12 months after they are earned, while Aerie points expire only after 375 days with no qualifying purchase. Eberjey has no points, but its benefits expire each December 31, and Savage X Fenty credits expire after 12 months. Each breakdown covers the rules in full.

Can you join a lingerie rewards program outside the US? Aerie's Real Rewards is open to Canada as well as the US. The other four programs are described in their breakdowns for US shoppers, and Eberjey's is limited to the continental US.

About the author
Graeme

Graeme

Co-Founder

Graeme is the co-founder at Mage Loyalty. He heads product development, from complex loyalty migrations and large-scale data handling to building the features shaping the future of loyalty.

Build a loyalty experience your customers remember.

See how modern Shopify brands use Mage to build stronger customer relationships and drive repeat revenue.

Trusted by
  • Reelie
  • Gelato Pique
  • MiaDonna
  • Tea Drops
  • West Coast Goalkeeping
  • Joy Dravecky
  • Love Sweat Fitness
  • The GoTo
  • Youswim

Related articles

Customer Acquisition Cost (CAC): Formula, Guide & Examples: a minimalist cinematic landscape with the title in the sky
Guides & Tips

Customer Acquisition Cost (CAC): Formula, Guide & Examples

Here is the most expensive belief in ecommerce finance: that a lower customer acquisition cost is always better. It sounds obvious. Spend less to win a customer, keep more profit. But that instinct quietly bankrupts brands, because customer acquisition cost (CAC) is meaningless on its own. A $10 CAC is a disaster if each customer is only worth $10. A $500 CAC is a gift if each customer returns $4,000. CAC only tells you anything when you set it next to what a customer is actually worth.

White text reading “Running a VIP Tier Program Cost” over a soft gradient background
Loyalty & Retention

How Much Does Running a VIP Tier Program Cost?

On Monday, the loyalty dashboard shows 84 customers in your top tier, and the finance report shows a higher-than-expected shipping bill. The VIP tier program cost is rarely the monthly software line. It sits inside the extra store credit, free shipping, gifts, and service promises attached to status.

White text reading “How Much Does a Loyalty Program Cost” on a soft gradient background.
Loyalty & Retention

How Much Does a Loyalty Program Cost to Maintain Each Year?

A loyalty program annual cost can run far beyond the subscription. One commercial software guide estimated $39,000 to $64,000 before custom development and ongoing maintenance. For Shopify merchants, the useful question is narrower: what will your program cost to run this year, and how much incremental contribution margin must it generate to earn that budget back?

Minimalist landscape with article title "Cost Per Retained Customer: The Metric That Should Sit Next to CAC" displayed in the
Loyalty & Retention

Cost Per Retained Customer: The Metric That Should Sit Next to CAC

Shopify store owners that fail to measure Cost Per Retained Customer often leave 25-95% of potential profit gains on the table, even while driving strong acquisition numbers.

Logos of Mage, Smile.io, BON Loyalty, Okendo, Rivo, Growave, Yotpo and LoyaltyLion on frosted glass tiles over a lavender gradient
Loyalty & Retention

Best Shopify Rewards Apps in 2027: 8 Loyalty Apps Compared

Eight Shopify loyalty and rewards apps compared on price, what each plan includes and how they feel to run, with hands-on notes and prices checked 11 November 2026 (Mage’s on 1 November 2026).

Best Shopify Loyalty App for Small Business in 2027: 6 Compared on Cost
Guides & Tips

Best Shopify Loyalty App for Small Business in 2027: 6 Compared on Cost

Six Shopify loyalty apps compared for small stores on what they cost at 500, 1,000 and 2,500 orders a month and what their cheapest plans include. Prices were read from vendor pages in November 2026.